Print this page
Published in News

Tesla sued for failing to fulfil technology promise

by on28 September 2021

You mean they will not have human androids out by the end of the year?

Elon Musk is famous for becoming a little too enthusiastic about his technology’s potential, this year he even claimed he would have a human android which was affordable available. However it appears his mouth might have got him into trouble down under.

Tesla's Big Battery, located in southern Australia, just got hit with a federal lawsuit for failing to provide the crucial grid support it once promised it could.

Built by Tesla in 2017, the 150-megawatt battery supplies 189 megawatt-hours of storage and was designed to support the grid when it becomes overloaded. Now operated by French renewable energy producer Neoen, it supplies storage for the adjacent Hornsdale wind farm, using clean energy to fill gaps that coal power leaves behind.

However, the Australian Energy Regulator (AER), the body that oversees Australian wholesale electricity and gas markets, announced it had filed a federal lawsuit against the Hornsdale Power Reserve (HPR) -- the energy storage system that owns the Tesla battery -- for failing to provide "frequency control ancillary services" numerous times over four months in the summer and fall of 2019.

Basically the battery was supposed to supply grid backup when a primary power source, like a coal plant, fails and apparently it didn’t work.

The HPR's alleged pattern of failures was first brought to light during a disruption to a nearby coal plant in 2019, according to the regulator.

When the nearby Queensland's Kogan Creek power station tripped on October 9, 2019, the HPR was called on to offer grid backup, having made offers to the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) to do so.

But the power reserve failed to provide the level of grid support that AEMO expected, and was never able to do so in the first place, the lawsuit alleges, despite making money off of offering them.

Though HPR did step in eventually, and no outages were recorded, the incident spurred an investigation into several similar failures throughout July to November 2019. The reserve's inability to support the grid in the way it promised created "a risk to power system security and stability", a press release on the lawsuit says.

At the time Tesla talked the battery up as being the largest lithium-ion battery in the world -- although it's now been superseded by another Tesla battery, the 300-megawatt Victorian Big Battery, also in Australia, which caught fire in July.

Last modified on 28 September 2021
Rate this item
(1 Vote)