Search engine outfit Google has managed to annoy some of America’s largest school districts by telling them they could lose access to Google Search if they refuse to accept its Gemini AI features.
According to The Verge, education authorities in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago have been considering alternatives after discovering that Google’s plans for next year could leave them unable to use Search without enabling the company’s artificial intelligence technology.
Google vice-president of education Chris Phillips explained that Search and AI had become so closely integrated that schools disabling Gemini-powered features would lose access to the search service. Apparently, the technology has reached the point where finding information on the internet requires an artificial intelligence assistant, whether teachers want one or not.
The announcement went down about as well as might be expected among educators who have been trying to control the use of AI in classrooms. Schools are increasingly concerned about students using chatbots to complete assignments without learning much beyond the art of copying and pasting.
New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani had already introduced restrictions preventing younger pupils from using AI in the classroom. His administration was therefore less than impressed with Google’s suggestion that schools might have to accept its technology to retain access to ordinary web searches.
Mamdani and US senator Bernie Sanders were among the politicians who criticised Google’s approach, with the word “extortion” appearing in the argument. It is probably unfortunate for Google’s public relations department when elected officials start describing a proposed product integration in terms normally associated with organised crime.
New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels warned that the district would investigate other search providers if Google refused to reconsider. Chicago’s public schools reportedly delivered a similar message, suggesting that the search giant’s enthusiasm for AI might finally encourage some customers to discover that other search engines exist.
The problem for schools is that Google has spent years making itself an essential part of their computing infrastructure. Chromebooks and Google Classroom are widely used throughout American education, making the prospect of abandoning the company’s services considerably more complicated than changing a browser’s default search setting.
Google has since attempted to calm the argument by explaining that it is revising the controls available to schools. Spokesperson Laura Breen told The Verge that the company was responding to concerns from parents and teachers about pupils using AI to avoid doing their own work.
Under the revised approach planned for next year, Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Search will be disabled by default until schools decide which services they want to enable. Google says it is developing the controls with educators, although the statement does not fully explain how independently the services will operate.
The company is introducing Guided Learning features intended to help students work through complicated problems without simply handing them completed answers. Google hopes this will reassure teachers who are concerned that AI assistants could undermine the reasoning skills schools are supposed to develop.
Evidence supports those concerns, with research suggesting that students who rely heavily on AI assistance can perform worse when tested without it. Educators have warned that allowing chatbots to complete assignments creates an obvious problem when pupils are later expected to demonstrate what they have learned.
Google’s original proposal has produced an awkward situation for a company which wants to make Gemini an unavoidable part of everyday computing. The largest American school districts are now considering alternatives, while Google has promised revised controls before its planned changes take effect next year.







