Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron have failed to convince a US federal judge to throw out a lawsuit accusing them of conspiring to restrict memory supplies and send DRAM prices through the roof.
Judge Noël Wise, in the Northern District of California, ruled that the allegations against the world’s three largest memory manufacturers were credible enough to allow an antitrust class action to proceed.
The case was brought by 17 consumers and small businesses who claim the companies coordinated production cuts, abandoned older memory technologies and diverted manufacturing capacity towards more profitable high-bandwidth memory (HBM).
The plaintiffs allege these decisions helped drive conventional DRAM prices up by nearly 700 per cent over 18 months, including retail price increases of about 500 per cent in a single year.
The manufacturers insist their decisions were independent commercial responses to changing market conditions and the enormous demand for memory used in AI accelerators. However, the judge found several aspects of their behaviour sufficiently suspicious to warrant further examination.
The companies argued that competitors in highly concentrated industries naturally monitor each other’s activities, comparing their behaviour to hawks watching one another.
Judge Wise was unimpressed, observing that the allegations resembled “hawks flying in formation”, something the birds are generally less inclined to do.
The lawsuit examines a series of production decisions beginning in late 2022, when SK Hynix and Micron announced cuts within three weeks of each other. Samsung followed in April 2023, despite having previously indicated it would maintain production.
All three subsequently redirected substantial manufacturing resources towards HBM, the specialised stacked memory used alongside powerful AI processors.
That decision made commercial sense while HBM commanded higher margins. However, the plaintiffs argue that the companies continued restricting conventional DRAM production even after ordinary memory became exceptionally profitable.
The court found this allegation particularly interesting because manufacturers would normally be expected to increase production when prices climb dramatically.
Instead, the plaintiffs claim the three companies delayed manufacturing investments and failed to expand conventional DRAM capacity.
Another contentious issue concerns DDR4 memory. Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron announced plans to wind down mainstream DDR4 production within the same three-month period in 2025, despite the technology remaining widely used in PCs and servers.
The resulting shortages allegedly became so severe that older DDR4 memory cost more per gigabyte than newer DDR5 products.
Judge Wise considered the timing of those announcements sufficient to support the plaintiffs’ allegation of coordinated behaviour.
The court was less persuaded by similar allegations concerning DDR3, noting that Micron had continued manufacturing limited quantities of the older technology.
The lawsuit further points to Micron’s decision to discontinue its Crucial consumer memory brand in December 2025, despite exceptionally high memory prices.
The plaintiffs argue that abandoning an established and profitable business during a period of soaring demand makes little commercial sense unless manufacturers have some assurance about their competitors’ behaviour. The judge found the decision relevant when considered alongside other alleged restrictions on conventional DRAM supplies.
Another allegation concerns customer vetting procedures introduced by all three manufacturers in January 2026. The companies reportedly began asking customers similar questions about their intended buyers, order quantities and whether demand was genuine.
The plaintiffs claim these procedures could have helped the manufacturers monitor and control memory distribution. There is some uncomfortable history here. Samsung and Hynix previously paid substantial fines following a US Department of Justice investigation into an earlier DRAM price-fixing cartel.
Samsung paid $300 million, while Hynix paid $185 million. Micron received immunity after cooperating with investigators. That previous case concerned conduct between 1998 and 2002 and provides no proof of wrongdoing in the present dispute.
The defendants argue that the current lawsuit repeats allegations from an unsuccessful 2018 antitrust case, which was eventually dismissed. But Judge Wise rejected that argument, finding that the new complaint contains additional allegations sufficient to distinguish it from the earlier litigation.
The companies have until 7 December 2026 to submit their formal responses, with an initial case management conference scheduled for 12 January 2027.







